Reply to Thread

Post a reply to the thread: Fan Clutch issue

Your Message

Click here to log in

Please correctly re-type the phrase f o o t d o c t o r in the form box. Re-type it without the extra spaces and put the one space where it should be. We apologize for having to do this but this silliness helps slow the spammers.


Additional Options


Topic Review (Newest First)

  • 11-15-2010, 12:23 AM

    when you installed them back, you left them loose

    The fan blade was was not properly set on the clutch and even though you tightened them, they got loose once they got seated.

    Those bolts are unheard of coming loose. But to avoid this, use a light thread blocked next time. (blue colored) and cross tighten them, but do not over tighten them either. When you say they are too short, could it be that they broke in half ? And you still have the other half stuck in the clutch ? in that case forget the Wheaties in the morning and use a torque wrench with a new bolts/clutch. It would be next to impossible to get the remaining half of the bolt from the clutch

    1997 BMW 840CiA
    1990 BMW Z1
    1999 BMW 528iT (Hauler mobile)
    2002 Astro Van AWD
    2003 Nissan 350Z Enthusiast Package
    1987 BMW 535i with 5spd manual (for sale)
    1992 BMW 735iL (needs head and interior)
    1977 BMW 320i (project racecar)
    2007 Mazda CX9 AWD (Wife mobile)
    1998 Yamaha Blaster+Breeze

    1995 850CSI CD00177 (SOLD)
  • 11-14-2010, 10:39 PM
    Joel Shandalow

    Re: Fan Clutch issue


    Thanks for the input. I am sure you are correct. I had already ordered another one. Just wanted to see as much as I could, what was going on with the blade and clutch.

    Still don't know why those screws worked loose
  • 11-14-2010, 06:21 PM

    Re: Fan Clutch issue

    Hate to state the obvious, but the fan shroud serves a purpose. Are you sure you haven't compromized the airflow (cooling) by sawing part of it away?

    2001 530i 5sp
  • 11-14-2010, 01:34 PM

    Re: Fan Clutch issue


    My car is a 528I. I've taken a closer look and found the fan was attached to the clutch with just one of the three original nuts. And it was already hand loose. Found another nut at the bottom of the shroud. So I have been able to remove the last loose nut and the fan. The fan doesnt look broken in any way.

    Now the nut is just a one inch hex nut (#4 on the top) which fit in tightly but was/is not long enough to extend very far into the clutch. Certainly not long enough to bolt through the clutch.

    Do you think just replacing with three longer nuts (and bolts) should work? Any thing obviously wrong with nuts extending further into the clutch itself? Given of course they dont extend so far as to hit something behind the clutch. I believe I installed the fan to the clutch correctly because it was my third configuration attempt and the only one that provided sufficient clearance. Yet I'm hard pressed to think these nuts would come off so easily.

    My shroud was already in pretty bad shape so I sawed away enough that I think I can re-attach the fan from the top.

    Would appreciate your thoughts very much, thanks again
  • 11-13-2010, 09:19 PM

    Re: Fan Clutch issue

    Which E39 do you have?

    On the 540s I've worked on, you can simply remove a detached fan from behind the shroud. On my 528 the 528 can rest inside of the shroud against the radiator and it isn't "flopping around".

    What kind of trouble were you having mounting the fan blades? From having swapped blades on clutches about 5 times, I don't recall anything that could possibly be troublesome.

    Any chance of providing a pic? Even a cellphone pic? We might be misunderstanding each other.
  • 11-13-2010, 07:47 PM

    Re: Fan Clutch issue

    I thought there were 4 10mm bolts? When you said you tightened them plenty, is it possible you stripped them and didn't realize it? That's only thing I can think as I nver heard that happen before.

    1998 BMW 540i 6 speed
    Arctic silver, M sport suspension (euro delivery), prod. date 05/98, non VANOS
    Staggered 18" style 32 OEM wheels
    3.15 open differential
    Remus exhaust
    AFE CAI with improved heat shield
    Z3 shifter
    VDO oil pressure and temperature gauges in place of headlight/fog switches
    Powder coated valve covers-satin black
    CDV delete
    AEA DRL module (aftermarket daytime running lights)

    1997 BMW 528iA
    Alpine white, premium package, prod. date 04/97, single VANOS
    Staggered 17" style 32 OEM wheels
    AEA DRL module
    Custom made sun blinds for rear seating area

    2000 Nissan Frontier Desert Runner, AKA "The Work Horse"

    Garage aids:
    Direct Lift Pro Park 8
    Campbell Hausfeld 28 gallon oil lubricated air compressor
    Newair ACP-1400H portable air conditioner and heater
    Auto Enginuity scan tool with BMW enhanced option
    Actron 9135 scan tool-for quick readouts

  • 11-13-2010, 06:44 PM

    Re: Fan Clutch issue


    Thanks for responding. The fan is totally off the clutch. I can move it around but of course can't get it out because of the shroud. I remember having trouble getting the fan properly mounted with the three hex screws but finally got it the only way it would fit and I tightened those hex screws plenty well.

    Have you ever heard of these working their way loose despite 2,000 miles with NO problems? Is it likely I will need to replace the clutch again as well as the fan itself? Even with the fan clattering against the shroud I was able to drive home without any change in engine temperature.

    I havent gotten underneath yet but there doesnt appear to be any wobble in the clutch or pump. There was wobble in the old pump which caused the problem (shredded belt) to begin with.

    Thanks for any recommendation
  • 11-13-2010, 12:52 PM

    Re: Fan Clutch issue

    Do you mean that the three hex head screws that attach the plastic blades to the fan had come loose?

    Or do you have play and wobble in the clutch or the water pump?

    The left-hand threads tighten from the rotation of the engine - they aren't just going to loosen in normal use.

  • 11-13-2010, 11:45 AM

    Fan Clutch issue

    I'd like to hear members "take" on the following. I have a high mileage (230,000) e39 which I have owned for three years. Recently replaced the fan,fan clutch, water pump and belts. Ran perfectly for 2,000 miles!!!

    Last week I heard a rattling which got louder and louder. Opened the hood and the fan had come off the clutch and was hitting the fan shroud.

    I havent yet had time to jack the car up and look further but.....Has anyone ever heard of this happening? I had used special tools to remove old fan and fan clutch recognizing the parts spun on counter clockwise.
    I must have done it correctly as I drove 2,000 miles without a hint of a problem.

    Just wondered if anyone has run into something like this before . Any insights greatly appreciated. I love this car and was initially very proud of having done the work myself. Now???????? jlshand

Posting Permissions

  • You may post new threads
  • You may post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
1e2 Forum