Wow, that's some wicked picture of the failed
rear shock mount with the shock shaft protruding all the way into the trunk space.
I'm sure this Rogue mount would be robust enough to last as long as the Turner units, but I like the Turner units because the bolts come up from the bottom, making it easy to put the nuts on the top and torque them properly. As I recall, the bolts are captive, so it is a one person job to get them up into place.
I also like the machine turned look of the Al mounts, but admit that no one will ever see these after they are installed. I had fun admiring them before I installed them.