+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 19 of 19
-
01-05-2007 02:02 AM #1
-
-
01-05-2007 08:07 PM #2
-
01-05-2007 08:10 PM #3
-
01-05-2007 10:31 PM #4
-
01-08-2007 12:59 PM #5
-
01-08-2007 01:22 PM #6
-
01-08-2007 11:17 PM #7
- Location
- Vancouver, WA, United States
Member No: 124244
- Join Date
- Apr 2005
- Posts
- 29
- Rep Power
- 0
Yup - that's me.
I got tired of tracking a 4000lb+ car because of the eternal penalty of the weight in the turns. You can do amazing things to keep a car like the S4 level through turning sequences, but you can never negate the laws of physics when it comes to inertia and traction. I did about 18 events in the S4 Avant and went through a lot of rubber before giving up on heavy cars for performance.
I took the attitude that I really needed 2 cars to replace the S4 - the X3 as a touring car that could carry lots of stuff, have lots of traction in nasty weather and be able to leave the pavement like I couldn't do with the S4 in the first place. The second vehicle is my current track toy - a Honda S2000. At 2700 lbs I got my wish to be able to do amazing feats in the turns without considering my tires to be expendable resources and have had a blast at the track.
I have done several BMW club group drives with our X3 and am still amazed at how well it really does handle for a tall car. In our case, we got a 2.5i with a manual tranny and no sports package. My goal was a smooth riding road trip car that wouldn't leave me cringing when I left the paved roads. The X3 achieved that in spades. What I didn't expect was the fact that the same vehicle with 17" wheels could leave a lot of Audi and BMW sedans scrambling to keep up with me in the turns on twisty roads.
I am very impressed with how BMW got a 50/50 weight distribution out of this critter and how well it responds to incredibly subtle throttle/steering inputs in the turns. I honestly had been drinking the Audi Kool-Aid far too long and really had overlooked just how nicely a well balanced car could make surgery out of a set of twisty roads. The notion that I am doing this in an SUV still leaves my jaw on the floor.
The new engines might make a difference, but I still do not expect the X3 to meet my track habit level of sports car performance and I think it would be unfair to think that it could. At the same time I have to confess that BMW did a pretty good job of making a stab at that goal anyway.
-
01-09-2007 09:19 AM #8
-
01-09-2007 11:53 PM #9
-
01-10-2007 10:16 PM #10
Statements like that will get you hung up . . .
. . . by your toes on the audiword board, right? I think the X3 is the most hated and loathed vehicle on the board by far. Knowledgeable folks over there, but I think they generally fail to realize how good the X3 is as an all around solution.
Rick
'04 Jet Black 3.0 6-speed, PP,terracotta, xenons, premium sound, PDC, heated seats, privacy glass, sat prep., Dinan strut tower brace, Y-Spoke, Goodyear Eagle F1 - 235/50/18 F, 255/45/18 R (Dunlop Wintersport M3s for winter).
'02 M5, Bluewater/caramel
-
01-10-2007 11:46 PM #11
- Location
- Vancouver, WA, United States
Member No: 124244
- Join Date
- Apr 2005
- Posts
- 29
- Rep Power
- 0
I think that's 2004 and earlier models
I read a lot of similar reviews (maybe the same ones) and since I was looking for a road trip car that could leave the pavement I skipped the sports pack and went for 17" wheels with lots of rubber. My goal was to not be nervous about bending a rim whilst wandering off the paved roads and also not feel like I got my teeth kicked down my throat after 6 or 7 hours of driving on non freeway type road surfaces.
It looks like BMW softened up the suspension a bunch in 2005 and my fears about that were unfounded. What I have is maybe a little soft for someone looking exclusively at performance on the pavement, but quite nice for cruising on gravel/dirt roads with washboard surfaces. I still would not want the 18" wheels because the lower profile tires are not suitable for where I want to drive my X3 in the Cascades around where I live - far too easy to bend a rim when things aren't smooth.
It's nice that we got so many options to choose from to dial in the type of driving you have in mind when you order one of these up.
-
01-10-2007 11:53 PM #12
- Location
- Vancouver, WA, United States
Member No: 124244
- Join Date
- Apr 2005
- Posts
- 29
- Rep Power
- 0
By the toes and what happens after that
would probably be unmentionable on a public forum :)
I do still drive with the Audi Club in my area and quite a number of folks have asked enough questions about driving a balanced car that I do see some seeds of doubt amongst the cult members.
For the True Believers(TM) however I think they see me with horns and a tail.....
-
01-11-2007 07:01 PM #13
-
01-11-2007 10:04 PM #14
-
01-11-2007 11:04 PM #15
Re: was x-drive reprogrammed for 2007 or later?
At relatively slower speeds and full lock turns, it seems to push like a pig. On higher speed 50-60mph decending radius turns, feels to drift pretty nuetrally. H&R Springs has a part number for sway bars, so you could probably dial it in, but not sure if they ever finished development on it. Never heard of anyone who has them.
Rick
'04 Jet Black 3.0 6-speed, PP,terracotta, xenons, premium sound, PDC, heated seats, privacy glass, sat prep., Dinan strut tower brace, Y-Spoke, Goodyear Eagle F1 - 235/50/18 F, 255/45/18 R (Dunlop Wintersport M3s for winter).
'02 M5, Bluewater/caramel
-
01-12-2007 04:11 AM #16
-
01-12-2007 10:08 PM #17
-
01-16-2007 10:25 PM #18
-
01-16-2007 10:27 PM #19
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks